Soft honey gingerbread cookies that never go hard
St. Nicholas Day Baking: Gingerbread, Treat Bags and Baking with Kids
St. Nicholas Day Baking: Gingerbread, Treat Bags and Baking with Kids
Updated Nov 3, 2026
St. Nicholas Day baking is mostly about gingerbread cookies: you decorate them as St. Nicholas, the devil and the angel, and they hold up well in a treat bag. The gifts are handed out on the evening of December 5, so bake honey gingerbread no later than the last week of November to give it time to soften. Alongside it go a few sturdy cookies, such as Linzer cookies, plus an apple or a clementine. Here's what to bake, how to decorate and pack it so nothing goes soft, and how to get through the whole afternoon with kids.
What to bake for St. Nicholas Day
The best bakes for St. Nicholas Day are ones that keep for a few days in a treat bag and can be decorated: gingerbread cookies, Linzer cookies, sturdy biscuits and figures made from yeast dough. Delicate cookies that break or get squashed in a bag, such as vanilla crescents and cookies filled with cream, are best saved for your Christmas cookie tin.
Gingerbread cookies are the foundation. They hold their shape, take decoration well and keep for a month. If you don't want to wait for them to soften, bake soft honey gingerbread that doesn't go hard or tender soft gingerbread.
Linzer cookies cut into little stars and hearts. A plain round is sturdy and holds up in a bag, so sandwich it with jam only just before packing on St. Nicholas Day. The method is in our recipe for tender Linzer cookies.
Cocoa "devil" cookies: just a simple butter cookie dough with cocoa added. Dark dough with red icing horns looks like a little devil, and kids love them.
Yeast dough figures for the morning of December 6: a soft, sweet little bear or little man. For example, a St. Nicholas bear from yeast dough.
With gingerbread, both softness and final look depend on baking temperature and time. See what temperature to bake gingerbread at, depending on thickness.
Soft honey gingerbread for St. Nicholas Day that doesn't go hard
Classic christmas cookies: delicate linzer cookies
St. Nicholas Day Linzer cookies: stars and hearts
St nicholas haribo bear meringue loaf (or any-occasion treat)
Yeast dough St. Nicholas bear for the morning of December 6
Want to know what’s next every Thursday until Christmas?
How to soften gingerbread that’s gone hard, when to fill Linzer cookies and how to tell the carp is done. One recipe and one tip a week. Unsubscribe in one click.
When to bake gingerbread for St. Nicholas Day so it's soft
Bake classic honey gingerbread 7–14 days before the gifts are handed out, so between November 21 and 28. If you bake it until dark brown, start as early as mid-November. Right out of the oven it's hard, and it softens gradually as it draws moisture from the air around it. Darker-baked cookies take longer to soften, sometimes several weeks.
If you have time: make the classic honey dough in late November and let the cookies mature in a tin. For how to store them so they soften faster, see how to store gingerbread so it softens.
If you're short on time: choose a recipe for gingerbread that's soft right away. Then you only need to bake 2–3 days ahead.
Decorating? Icing needs 12–24 hours to dry completely. So schedule the decorating for December 3 at the latest, so you aren't packing sticky cookies.
St. Nicholas gingerbread is often the first batch of the whole Christmas season. To follow it up with the rest of your cookies, see the calendar of when to bake Christmas cookies by type.
How to decorate St. Nicholas gingerbread: red, black and white
For St. Nicholas gingerbread, all you need is white royal icing made with egg white and two colors: red for St. Nicholas's cloak and the devil's horns, black for the devil. Always mix both colors from gel colors, not liquid ones. Liquid color thins the icing, which then runs and dries poorly.
Red is the hardest. A small amount of color turns pink. Add gel color to the icing a toothpick tip at a time and let it rest for an hour or two, during which time the color darkens on its own. ProGel ruby gel color gives a deep ruby red with a slightly wine-colored undertone; for a warmer, "St. Nicholas" red, mix in a drop of yellow. For how to get a truly red icing, see red icing for gingerbread.
Go easy on black. First darken the icing with a teaspoon of cocoa, and only then add black gel color. You'll need much less of it, and the icing won't have the bitter aftertaste that a large amount of color can leave. You'll find more on deep black in black frosting and black icing.
Leave white white. Make beards, angel wings and the trim on St. Nicholas's hat with uncolored icing. To make it stand out on dark gingerbread, thicken it with a little powdered sugar. Egg white icing has a naturally slightly yellowish tone; a super white icing color, stirred in before you color the batch, turns it pure white.
Dose by the label. ProGel gel colors have a maximum dose of 3 g per 1 kg of icing, and for a bowl of icing made from one egg white, a few toothpick tips are enough. The ruby, yellow and black all contain azo dyes (E122, E129, E102) and carry a warning that they may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children.
You'll find gel colors in every shade in the colors and food dyes for decorating gingerbread category. If you want to dig deeper into icings (ratios, consistency, when to use which), read the overview of icing types for cookies. You don't have to throw away leftover icing; see how to store royal icing and how long it lasts.
What to put in a St. Nicholas treat bag and how to pack it so it stays dry
A classic St. Nicholas bag holds a gingerbread cookie, a few other cookies, an apple or a clementine, nuts and a small sweet. To keep everything in good shape, pack each moist item separately.
Let everything cool and dry out completely. Warm bakes steamed in a bag go soft, and the icing smudges.
Don't put fruit in the same sealed bag as cookies. Apples and clementines release moisture, and delicate Linzer cookies would be soft by morning. Put the fruit loose in the stocking or basket and the baked goods in their own bag.
Pack soft gingerbread apart from crisp cookies. Moisture moves from soft to dry: the gingerbread dries out and the crisp cookies go soft.
Bag decorated gingerbread one at a time, or put parchment paper between them. Dry icing doesn't rub off, but it cracks when the cookies rub against each other.
Put the bag together 1–2 days ahead, not a week. The gingerbread will keep, but fruit and nuts lose quality in the warmth.
For general principles on storing baked goods so they stay crisp, see how to store Christmas cookies.
How to bake with kids for St. Nicholas Day so everyone has fun
Split your St. Nicholas baking with kids into two days: dough and cutting out on the first day, decorating on the second. Young children can't last a whole afternoon in one go, and you won't have to rush with the finished dough.
Make the dough yourself, even a day ahead. Chilled in the fridge, it rolls out more easily and sticks less. The kids join in at the cutting-out stage.
Roll the dough thicker, 5–6 mm (about ¼ inch). Thicker cookies break less when you move them and stand up better to children's decorating. You'll find more tips in how to cut out cookies so they hold their shape.
Divide the jobs by age:
Ages 3–5: cutting out with big shapes, scattering sprinkles and brushing.
Ages 6–9: decorating with icing from a piping bag with a small tip, and simple pictures (devil's horns, St. Nicholas's beard).
Ages 10+: decorating on their own, mixing colors and watching the baking time.
Add sprinkles straight onto wet icing. They won't stick to icing that has dried. Set them out in bowls so the kids have them ready right next to the cookie.
Icing for the littlest ones. Royal icing made with fresh egg white isn't heated. For small children, make it with pasteurized egg white, or reach for an egg-free icing for gingerbread.
The oven stays an adult's job. The baking sheet is over 150 °C (300 °F), and a burn from a hot sheet happens fast and hurts, so only an adult handles the sheet and the oven.
It doesn't matter if a cookie isn't perfect. A child would rather eat a crooked devil they decorated themselves than the prettiest one you made.
How to follow St. Nicholas baking with Christmas cookies
You bake St. Nicholas gingerbread in late November, roughly 1–2 weeks before the main Christmas batch, so it lets you test your dough, your oven's real temperature and your icing consistency. Whatever goes wrong, you can fix for the Christmas cookies. If you make a larger batch of dough, the rest can go straight into the freezer.
For how long each type of cookie keeps, see the overview of cookie shelf life by type.
For how to freeze dough and finished cookies and thaw them so they don't go soft, see how to freeze cookies and dough.
For when Linzer cookies are at their best and why they benefit from resting, see how long Linzer cookies keep.
What you'll need for decorating St. Nicholas gingerbread
Frequently asked questions
When are the St. Nicholas gifts given, December 5 or 6?
In Czechia, St. Nicholas visits on the evening of December 5, the eve of St. Nicholas Day, which falls on December 6. He comes with the devil and the angel on the evening of December 5. If children put a stocking outside the window, they'll find their treats on the morning of December 6.
Why does colored icing on St. Nicholas gingerbread bleed into the white?
Color bleeds when the icing is too thin or when you pipe a colored section next to white icing that hasn't dried yet. Always mix colors using gel colors, not liquid ones, and let the icing dry for at least an hour between colors. Don't leave decorated cookies in a humid room.
What can I put in a St. Nicholas treat bag for a child with a nut allergy?
For a child with a nut allergy, leave out nuts and anything that contains or may contain them. Watch out for Linzer cookies made with ground nuts, gingerbread decorated with almonds, and store-bought sweets labeled "may contain traces of nuts". Good choices are homemade gingerbread made from a nut-free dough (but check the flour, gingerbread spice and decorations too, as they may also carry a traces-of-nuts warning), fruit, and a small toy. If you also bake with nuts at home, bake the allergic child's batch first, on a clean baking sheet with clean utensils. For a confirmed or severe allergy, follow your allergist's advice; this is general guidance, not medical advice.
Can I bake St. Nicholas gingerbread ahead and freeze it?
Yes, undecorated gingerbread cookies and raw gingerbread dough keep in the freezer at −18 °C (0 °F) for 2–3 months. Thaw them for 2–3 hours in a closed container at room temperature so moisture doesn't condense on them, and decorate only after thawing. You'll find the method in our article on how to freeze cookies and dough.
What can I put in a St. Nicholas treat bag instead of sweets?
Instead of sweets, put in fruit, one homemade gingerbread cookie and a small treat that will delight a child for longer than a candy. An apple, clementines or dried fruit work well, and for older children, nuts in the shell. Non-edible ideas include colored pencils, stickers, a small book or warm socks. One gingerbread cookie is enough to keep the whole bag smelling of St. Nicholas.
Want tips like this every Thursday?
One recipe worth heating the oven for, one tip, and one deal from the shop. Nothing else.