Choose your cookies

Necessary cookies hold the site together — cart, sign-in, language. Analytics ones show us what works here and what to build your recommendations on. Marketing ones would measure ads outside Yumsto; we're not running any yet. Nothing but the necessary ones runs until you say yes.

How we handle your data

Cookie settings

Potato Salad: Classic Czech Christmas Recipe, Variations and How Much per Person

Potato Salad: Classic Czech Christmas Recipe, Variations and How Much per Person

A close view of a bowl of Czech potato salad with diced potatoes, pickles, carrot and chopped egg, topped with fresh parsley, centred on a plain kitchen table.

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Potato salad is as much a must on the Czech Christmas Eve table as the carp: potatoes boiled in their skins, root vegetables, onion, pickled gherkins, eggs and mayonnaise, mixed a day ahead so the flavors come together. Below you'll find the classic step-by-step recipe with amounts for 4 and for 10 people, an explanation of why potato salad turns watery, and tried-and-tested variations: with no mayonnaise, with yogurt, with dill, a summer version with radishes, and a finely diced one for chlebíčky (Czech open-faced sandwiches). At the end there's a Christmas Eve game plan and how many days the salad keeps in the fridge.

Classic Potato Salad: Step-by-Step Recipe

Classic Czech potato salad is made from potatoes boiled in their skins, chilled overnight, diced and tossed with cooked carrot, parsley root and celery root, onion, pickles, hard-boiled eggs and mayonnaise. Then you let it rest in the fridge for at least 8 hours, ideally overnight. That's the whole secret; the rest is details that decide whether the salad turns out firm and juicy or mushy.

The mayonnaise version isn't an ancient tradition, by the way. According to historian Martin Franc, quoted by Blesk (opens in a new tab), potato salad only became a fixture of the Christmas Eve table after the Second World War; before that, if it was made at all, it was the Viennese type without mayonnaise. Blesk adds that the mayonnaise version then spread thanks to industrially made mayonnaise in the 1950s. That's why the mayonnaise-free version has every right to a place in this article.

Ingredients for Potato Salad for 4 and for 10 People

Count on roughly 250 g of unpeeled potatoes per person when the salad is the main side dish for carp or schnitzel. For more detailed calculations for big family tables, see the article how much carp and potato salad per person.

For 4 servings you'll need:

  • 1 kg type A (salad) potatoes

  • 1 carrot, 1 parsley root, a piece of celery root (about 250 g altogether)

  • 1 small onion (about 80 g)

  • 4–5 pickled gherkins (about 150 g) and 3–4 tablespoons of pickling liquid

  • 3 hard-boiled eggs

  • 200–250 g mayonnaise

  • 1 teaspoon full-fat mustard

  • salt, ground black pepper, a pinch of sugar

For 10 servings you'll need:

  • 2.5 kg type A potatoes

  • 2 carrots, 2 parsley roots, ¼ medium celery root (about 600 g altogether)

  • 2 onions (about 200 g)

  • 10–12 pickled gherkins (about 400 g) and 6–8 tablespoons of pickling liquid

  • 7–8 hard-boiled eggs

  • 500–600 g mayonnaise

  • 2–3 teaspoons full-fat mustard

  • salt, pepper and sugar to taste

Some people add peas, apple, ham or salami. Go ahead, but keep in mind that every extra ingredient increases the volume and takes away from the mayonnaise, so add a spoonful or two more.

Which Potatoes for Potato Salad

Potato salad calls for type A boiling potatoes, the so-called salad potatoes. They have firm, waxy flesh, don't fall apart when cooked and hold their cube shape once diced. Type B (all-purpose) will do if you have nothing else, but the salad will be softer. Type C (floury) is for mash and turns to purée in a salad.

Choose tubers of a similar size so they cook evenly. How to recognize salad potatoes in the store and which varieties have proved their worth is covered in the article which potatoes for potato salad.

How to Make Potato Salad: Boil in the Skins, Chill, Dice

You make potato salad in 8 steps: boil the potatoes in their skins, cook the root vegetables separately, let everything cool completely, dice, season the base without mayonnaise, fold in the mayonnaise and eggs, let it rest overnight, and adjust the seasoning before serving.

  1. Boil the potatoes in their skins. Put washed potatoes in cold salted water, bring to a boil and simmer gently for 20–30 minutes depending on size. They're done when a knife slides in with slight resistance, not completely soft. The skin keeps the starch inside and stops the potatoes from soaking up water. More on boiling in the article how to boil potatoes.

  2. Cook the root vegetables. Peel the carrot, parsley root and celery root and boil them whole or in large pieces in salted water for 15–20 minutes until tender. Save the cooking liquid; it's handy for the mayonnaise-free version or for soup.

  3. Let everything cool completely. Ideally overnight in the fridge, at minimum 3–4 hours. A cold potato cuts cleanly, a warm one smears and breaks. This is the step people skip most often, and then they wonder why they got mush.

  4. Peel and dice. Cut the potatoes into cubes of about 1 cm, the vegetables into smaller dice (5–7 mm), and the pickles the same. Chop the onion finely. Peel the eggs and dice them.

  5. Season the base before adding mayonnaise. Put the potatoes, vegetables, onion and pickles in a bowl, add salt, pepper, a pinch of sugar and 3–4 tablespoons of pickling liquid. Toss gently and leave for 10 minutes so the potatoes absorb the flavor.

  6. Add the mayonnaise and eggs. Stir the mayonnaise with the mustard, fold it into the salad and add the eggs last. Fold with a spatula from the bottom up rather than stirring in circles with a spoon, so you don't mash the potatoes.

  7. Let it rest overnight. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least 8 hours. Overnight, the tang of the pickles, the onion and the mayonnaise come together and the salad takes on its typical "Christmas" flavor.

  8. Adjust the seasoning before serving. A cold salad always tastes less salty and less tangy than a warm one. Taste it and add a spoonful of pickling liquid, some salt or a dollop of mayonnaise if needed.

What Goes into Potato Salad and Why

Classic potato salad contains type A potatoes, cooked root vegetables (carrot, parsley root, celery root), onion, pickled gherkins with their liquid, hard-boiled eggs, mayonnaise, and mustard and sugar for fine-tuning. Each has its job:

  • Potatoes are the backbone: neutral, starchy and good at absorbing flavor. That's why you season them first, before the mayonnaise.

  • Root vegetables add sweetness and color. They're cooked separately because carrot, parsley root and celery root need a different time than potatoes, and they're cut smaller so they don't overpower the potato cubes.

  • Onion brings a sharpness that cuts through the richness of the mayonnaise. If raw onion is too much for you, scald it in a sieve with hot water or cover it with pickling liquid for 10 minutes.

  • Pickles and their liquid are the source of tang. Without them the salad is bland and heavy; with too much liquid it turns watery.

  • Eggs add smoothness and a fuller flavor. Fold them in at the end, otherwise the yolk smears and the salad turns gray.

  • Mustard and sugar are for fine-tuning: mustard stabilizes the mayonnaise and adds depth, and a pinch of sugar rounds out the acidity of the pickling liquid.

Be careful with salt: the pickles, their liquid, the mustard and the mayonnaise already contain salt. Salt the potatoes lightly at the start and adjust the rest the next day.

How Much Mayonnaise for Potato Salad

Use 200–250 g of mayonnaise per 1 kg of potatoes. The lower end gives a salad where you can taste each ingredient and the cubes are merely coated; the upper end gives a creamy salad like the ones from a deli. More than 300 g per kilo drowns out the flavor.

Add the mayonnaise gradually: first two thirds, mix, taste. The salad will "drink up" a bit more overnight, as the potatoes absorb some of the mayonnaise, so in the morning you can add a spoonful or two. A richer mayonnaise (over 70% fat, often labeled "výběrová majonéza", or premium mayonnaise, on the jar) keeps the salad compact. If you want a less creamy, fresher salad, choose a mayonnaise with less fat; what matters is the fat content stated on the label, not the name itself.

How to Tell Your Potato Salad Turned Out Well

You can tell a good potato salad the next morning by three things: the potato cubes hold their shape, there's no puddle at the bottom of the bowl, and the flavor is balanced between creaminess, the tang of the pickles and the sharpness of the onion. The potato cubes have crisp edges and aren't mashed or grainy. The mayonnaise coats them like a glossy cream, with no liquid pooling in the bowl. And the flavor is balanced: first a gentle creaminess, then the tang of the pickles and finally a light bite from the onion and mustard, with no one component overpowering the others.

When a salad tastes flat, it's almost always missing tang or salt, not mayonnaise. Add a spoonful of pickling liquid, stir, wait five minutes and taste again. If it's too sour instead, a pinch of sugar and an extra spoonful of mayonnaise will help.

Want to know what’s next every Thursday until Christmas?

How to soften gingerbread that’s gone hard, when to fill Linzer cookies and how to tell the carp is done. One recipe and one tip a week. Unsubscribe in one click.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

Why Is Potato Salad Watery

Potato salad turns watery mainly for three reasons: the potatoes were still warm when diced or were overcooked, too much pickling liquid went in, or the pickles and vegetables released juice that the salt drew out overnight. It helps to boil the potatoes in their skins and let them cool completely, pat the pickles dry before cutting, measure the liquid by the spoonful, and salt less and adjust the seasoning the next day. Thin yogurt also releases whey. If it has already happened to you, how to rescue the salad (and why adding more mayonnaise won't help) is in the article why is potato salad watery.

Potato Salad with No Mayonnaise

Potato salad with no mayonnaise is made in two ways: with a vinegar-and-oil dressing, or "Austrian style" with warm broth. Both are less creamy than the mayonnaise classic, and older. The potatoes are cooked the same way for both, in their skins and until firm, but here they're cut while still lukewarm, because a warm potato absorbs dressing far better than a cold one.

Which to choose? The vinegar-and-oil version is sharper, quick, and suits fish. The Austrian one with broth is gentler, creamier and goes best with schnitzel. Both taste best on the day you make them, lukewarm or at room temperature; overnight in the fridge they stiffen and the potatoes turn dense.

Potato Salad with Vinegar and Oil

For 1 kg of potatoes, mix 4 tablespoons of vinegar (distilled or apple cider), 5–6 tablespoons of oil, 1 teaspoon of mustard, 1 teaspoon of sugar, salt and pepper. Peel the lukewarm potatoes, cut them into slices about 5 mm thick and pour the dressing over them right away, together with finely chopped onion and pickles. Leave for 30 minutes, stir and adjust the seasoning. The potatoes will drink up most of the dressing, so you may need a spoonful more vinegar or oil. The finished salad is glossy, not wet, and tastes distinctly tangy and fresh.

A warm salad with bacon, sauerkraut and Krems mustard, with no mayonnaise, is part of the recipe grilled jitrnice with warm potato salad.

Grilled jitrnice (Czech white sausages) with warm potato and sauerkraut salad

Austrian Potato Salad with Broth

Austrian potato salad (Erdäpfelsalat) relies on hot broth, which makes the potatoes lightly creamy without a spoonful of mayonnaise. For 1 kg of potatoes, heat 150–200 ml of beef or vegetable broth (the liquid from cooking the root vegetables is fine) and stir in 3–4 tablespoons of vinegar, 1 teaspoon of sugar, 1 teaspoon of mustard, salt and pepper. Peel the potatoes while still warm, cut them into thin slices, add finely chopped onion and pour the hot mixture over them.

Let it sit for 20–30 minutes, stirring gently now and then; the starch from the edges of the slices forms a smooth, slightly sticky sauce with the broth. Only at the end stir in 3–4 tablespoons of oil and a handful of chopped chives. It's served lukewarm or at room temperature, and in Austria it's the standard side for schnitzel.

Potato Salad with Yogurt or Lower-Fat Mayonnaise

For potato salad with yogurt, replace half of the mayonnaise with thick plain yogurt, ideally a fuller-fat one. A 1:1 ratio keeps the creamy taste of the classic, but the salad is fresher and tangier. For 1 kg of potatoes that means 120 g mayonnaise and 120 g yogurt, stirred with a teaspoon of mustard and a pinch of sugar, which rounds out the tang of the yogurt.

Important details:

  • Thick yogurt only. Thin plain yogurt releases whey and the salad turns watery overnight. If you only have thin, let it drain for an hour in a sieve lined with a cloth.

  • No mayonnaise at all? It works. Add 2 tablespoons of oil to the yogurt so the salad has fat to carry the flavor. The result is tangier, so use less pickling liquid.

  • Lower-fat mayonnaise (check the fat content on the label) is used just like regular; add it gradually and taste as you go.

  • Quark (tvaroh, a Czech fresh curd cheese) or skyr work too: stir soft quark with a little milk until smooth and use it like yogurt. The salad is then denser and less creamy.

Let the yogurt salad rest overnight as well, but adjust the seasoning only in the morning, because yogurt mellows overnight and loses some of its tang.

For a warm version where yogurt with honey mustard replaces the mayonnaise, see the recipe warm potato salad with honey-mustard dressing.

Warm potato salad with honey-mustard dressing

Potato Salad with Dill

Potato salad with dill is a variation where you add a big bunch of fresh dill, about 20 g per 1 kg of potatoes. Chop the dill finely, stems included, since they have the most aroma, and fold it in together with the mayonnaise so it doesn't get bruised. It works best with a dressing of half mayonnaise and half sour cream or yogurt, a little lemon juice instead of vinegar, and dill pickles.

Overnight, dill darkens a little and its fragrance fades, so keep a small handful aside and stir it in just before serving. Dried dill is no substitute for fresh; it tastes faded and grassy, more like hay. If you have no other option, use 2 teaspoons and let it sit overnight.

Summer Potato Salad with Radishes

Summer potato salad with radishes is made with new potatoes boiled in their skins, which you don't need to peel, and crisp raw vegetables instead of cooked root vegetables. For 1 kg of new potatoes, add a bunch of radishes cut into thin rounds, half a cucumber diced, 2–3 scallions and a handful of dill or chives.

Make the dressing from 3 tablespoons of oil, 2 tablespoons of vinegar or lemon juice, a teaspoon of mustard, salt and pepper, or from yogurt with a little mayonnaise if you want a creamy version. Pour the dressing over the lukewarm potatoes and let them cool; mix in the radishes and cucumber just before serving. Otherwise the salt draws out their water, you get a puddle at the bottom of the bowl within an hour, and the radishes lose their crunch.

In summer, don't leave the salad standing outside for more than two hours, and if it's over 32°C (90°F), no more than one hour; this applies to the version with and without mayonnaise. Put the bowl in the shade or set it in a larger bowl of ice. You'll find more ideas in filling summer salads, and with green beans and smoked fish you get potato salad with green beans and smoked mackerel.

Potato salad with green beans and smoked mackerel

Potato Salad for Chlebíčky

Potato salad for chlebíčky (Czech open-faced sandwiches) is cut finer, into 5 mm cubes instead of 1 cm, and has to be thicker so it holds on the slice of baguette and doesn't slide off. Cook the potatoes and vegetables until firm, pat the pickles dry, use only 1–2 tablespoons of pickling liquid per kilo and go for the lower end of the mayonnaise (200 g per kilo), since the sandwich gets ham, egg and a garnish on top as well.

Grate the eggs for the sandwich salad finely; this thickens the salad and evens out the texture. Let it rest overnight and spoon it onto the baguette slice in a mound about 1.5 cm high, smooth it with a knife and only then layer on the ham, egg and pickle. Keep chlebíčky with mayonnaise salad in the fridge and serve the topped baguette within a few hours, before the bread goes soft.

Schnitzel with Potato Salad Outside Christmas

Schnitzel with potato salad is the most common year-round use of potato salad, and here you have more freedom than on Christmas Eve. Salad for a Sunday schnitzel doesn't need to rest all night; just mix it in the morning and leave it in the fridge for 4–6 hours. The yogurt version or the Austrian salad with broth goes brilliantly with fried meat, because their tang offsets the richness of the frying.

If you want less frying, try baked crispy cutlets in a cornmeal crumb; with a potato salad of new potatoes and radishes you get a summer lunch that works in the garden too. For the classic with pork, chicken or veal schnitzel, see the article schnitzel step by step.

If you want something other than a classic schnitzel to go with the salad, try Dutch-style cheese pork cutlets.

Dutch-style cheese pork cutlets

Potato Salad for Christmas Eve: What to Do When

For Christmas Eve it's best to have the potato salad finished by the evening of December 23; on the morning of the 24th you only taste it and adjust the seasoning. That way it rests overnight and the kitchen on Christmas Eve is left free for the carp and the soup.

  • December 22: buy type A potatoes, vegetables, pickles and mayonnaise (or eggs, if you're making your own). Hard-boil the eggs.

  • Afternoon of December 23: boil the potatoes in their skins and the root vegetables, and let them cool (on the balcony or in the fridge, not on a warm counter).

  • Evening of December 23: peel, dice, mix, cover and refrigerate.

  • Morning of December 24: taste and adjust with salt, pickling liquid or mayonnaise. Take the salad out of the fridge about half an hour before dinner so it isn't icy, but don't leave it sitting in the warmth all afternoon.

Didn't get to it the day before? Boil the potatoes on the morning of the 24th right after breakfast, peel them while still lukewarm, spread them in a single layer on a baking sheet and put them in the fridge or on a cold balcony for 1–2 hours. Mix the salad by noon; it has 5–6 hours before dinner, which is enough for the flavors to come together. It won't be as unified as after a whole night, but it's definitely better than a salad mixed an hour before the meal.

How much salad to make? For a Christmas Eve table that also has soup and carp, count on 250 g of potatoes per adult; if you have hungry teenagers at home or want salad for December 25th too, add a quarter more. The salad shouldn't be kept for more than two days, so a big stockpile "for the whole holidays" makes no sense.

If you're planning the whole holiday, see the Christmas menu with a prep plan. For everything about the carp, see the article carp for Christmas.

Homemade Mayonnaise for Potato Salad

Whisk homemade mayonnaise for potato salad from 2 egg yolks, 1 teaspoon of mustard, about 250 ml of neutral oil, 1–2 tablespoons of lemon juice or vinegar and salt; that's enough for 1 kg of potatoes. Have all the ingredients at room temperature. Whisk the yolks with the mustard and salt, then pour in the oil, drop by drop at first and, once the mixture starts to thicken, in a thin stream. Finally season with lemon.

If the mayonnaise breaks (the oil separates and it's thin and grainy), put a fresh yolk in a clean bowl and whisk the broken mayonnaise into it again, a spoonful at a time. An immersion blender in a narrow container does the whole thing in a minute, and breaking is rare with it.

Homemade mayonnaise gives the salad a gentler, butterier flavor than store-bought. But it's made with raw egg yolks, and that comes with rules; see below.

How Long Does Potato Salad Keep

Potato salad with mayonnaise keeps in the fridge for 2 days, counted from the moment you mix it. So if you make it on the evening of the 23rd, eat it by December 25th. Keep it covered, in the coldest part of the fridge (not in the door), and don't leave it standing on the table longer than necessary; serve yourself a portion and return the bowl.

Treat salad made with homemade mayonnaise from raw egg yolks as food for one day, two at most. Storage is covered in detail in the article how long does potato salad keep in the fridge. And if you do have something left after the holidays, you'll find inspiration in the article what to do with Christmas leftovers, and more potato dishes in the overview what to cook with potatoes.

Frequently asked questions

Does apple belong in potato salad?

Apple doesn't belong in classic Czech potato salad, but many families add it and it's a legitimate variation. For 1 kg of potatoes, one tart apple is enough, peeled and cut into tiny cubes. Add it only along with the mayonnaise so it doesn't turn brown, and use a little less sugar.

Can you freeze potato salad?

We don't recommend freezing potato salad. After thawing, the mayonnaise separates, the potatoes turn grainy and soft, and the pickles lose their crunch, so the salad ends up watery and unpleasantly mushy. It's better to make a smaller batch.

Can you put salami or ham in potato salad?

Yes, ham or a mild salami can go into potato salad, most often 100–150 g per 1 kg of potatoes, diced. On Christmas Eve, though, the salad is traditionally made without meat because of the fast. Add meat to a salad served with schnitzel or for chlebíčky instead.

What can replace pickled gherkins in potato salad?

You can replace the pickled gherkins with dill pickles, pickled pearl onions or capers, which give a similar tang. If you leave out the pickles altogether, season the salad with a spoonful of vinegar and a pinch of sugar, and add more mustard so the flavor isn't flat.

Is potato salad suitable for vegans?

Classic potato salad isn't vegan because of the eggs and mayonnaise, but it's easy to adapt. Leave out the eggs and use vegan mayonnaise, or make the vinegar-and-oil version or the Austrian one with vegetable broth, which contain no animal ingredients.

Can I steam the potatoes for potato salad?

Yes, you can steam the potatoes in their skins for potato salad, and the result is often even better than boiling, because the potatoes don't soak up water and stay drier and firmer. Allow 25–35 minutes depending on size and check doneness with a knife, just as you would when boiling.

Want tips like this every Thursday?

One recipe worth heating the oven for, one tip, and one deal from the shop. Nothing else.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

Cart