Choose your cookies

Necessary cookies hold the site together — cart, sign-in, language. Analytics ones show us what works here and what to build your recommendations on. Marketing ones would measure ads outside Yumsto; we're not running any yet. Nothing but the necessary ones runs until you say yes.

How we handle your data

Cookie settings

Banana Bread Substitutes for Butter, Oil, Eggs, Sour Cream and Sugar

Banana Bread Substitutes for Butter, Oil, Eggs, Sour Cream and Sugar

A realistic overhead food photo of a sliced banana bread loaf surrounded by small bowls of butter, oil, yogurt, applesauce, ground flaxseed and brown sugar on a light counter. No text, no people's faces.

Updated Nov 21, 2026

Banana bread takes substitutes well: you can swap butter and oil for each other, replace eggs with applesauce, yogurt or flax, use Greek yogurt for sour cream, and cut or change the sugar, as long as you keep the batter about as wet as the recipe intended. Each swap changes the texture a little, and stacking several at once is where loaves go gummy. Here is what each swap does and the amounts to use.

The one rule: keep the batter about as wet

Banana bread already carries a lot of water and sugar from the fruit. Most failed swaps add moisture (more yogurt, more banana, liquid sweeteners) or take away structure (no egg, less flour), and the loaf ends up gummy or sunken.

  • Change one or two things at a time, not everything at once.

  • Swap like for like: fat for fat, wet for wet.

  • Weigh where you can. A US stick of butter is 113 g and a US cup of butter 227 g; all-purpose flour is about 120–125 g per US cup (127–132 g per 250 ml metric cup); our tool uses 125 g and 132 g. The cups and spoons to grams calculator covers other amounts.

  • Expect a swapped loaf to need a few minutes more or less, and test the center rather than trusting the clock.

Butter and oil substitutes

Oil instead of butter. Butter is about 81% fat according to USDA FoodData Central; the rest is mostly water. Oil is all fat. So:

  • Use about three-quarters as much oil as butter by weight: about 85 g of oil for 113 g of butter.

  • Use a neutral oil such as sunflower or canola, or a mild olive oil if you like its taste.

  • The loaf will be softer and moister, and it stays soft for longer, but tastes less buttery.

Butter instead of oil. Use about 1¼ times the oil's weight in melted butter (for example 125 g of butter for 100 g of oil), which gives the same amount of fat. Butter is about 81% fat and the rest is mostly water. The loaf tastes richer and firms up more once cool.

Melted coconut oil works one for one in place of vegetable oil, but solidifies in the fridge, so the loaf is firm when cold.

Less fat or no fat: replace up to half the butter or oil with the same weight of unsweetened applesauce or plain yogurt. Going further makes a rubbery, dense loaf. Our guide to what to use instead of oil in cakes covers more options.

Egg substitutes for banana bread

Eggs bind and lift. Banana already binds well, so banana bread is one of the easiest bakes to make with fewer eggs or none.

Per large egg (about 50 g without the shell, by USDA FoodData Central):

  • Unsweetened applesauce: about 60 g. Moist and mild; the loaf is a little denser.

  • Plain or Greek yogurt: about 60 g. Good crumb, slight tang.

  • Flax egg: 1 tablespoon of ground flaxseed plus 3 tablespoons of water, left for 5 minutes until thick. Nutty, slightly darker crumb.

  • Extra mashed banana: about 60 g. Works for one egg, but more makes the loaf heavy.

  • Commercial egg replacer: follow the package.

Replacing one egg is barely noticeable. Replacing two or more gives a denser, moister loaf; a little extra baking powder (about ½ teaspoon) helps it rise. For other bakes, see our egg substitution chart by recipe.

Sour cream, yogurt and buttermilk substitutes

Sour cream adds fat, moisture and acid. The acid matters, because it helps baking soda rise.

  • Full-fat Greek yogurt: the best swap, weight for weight.

  • Plain yogurt: weight for weight; the batter is a little looser.

  • Crème fraîche: weight for weight, richer.

  • Buttermilk or kefir: thinner, so use about three-quarters of the sour cream's weight.

  • Milk with a squeeze of lemon: in a pinch; use about three-quarters as much, as with buttermilk.

In Czech shops you'll find zakysaná smetana (cultured sour cream), which works one for one. For ratios and how each swap changes the crumb, see substitutes for Greek yogurt and sour cream in batter and buttermilk substitutes.

Sugar substitutes and cutting the sugar

Sugar sweetens, but it also keeps banana bread moist and helps it brown.

  • Brown sugar for white: one for one by weight. Moister, darker, a light caramel taste. Light and dark brown both work.

  • White sugar for brown: one for one; the loaf is paler and a little drier. Adding a spoon of honey or molasses brings some of the flavor back.

  • Honey or maple syrup: replace up to half the sugar. Both add liquid, so cut back a little on any milk or yogurt, and expect a darker crust; many bakers lower the oven by about 15 °C (25 °F). Honey is 21 g per tablespoon.

  • Cutting the sugar: most cake-style recipes take a 10% cut without noticeable change; up to about 25% works in many banana breads, with a paler, drier loaf. Use very ripe bananas to make up for it.

  • Sugar replacers: erythritol and similar sweeteners behave differently in baking; see which sugar substitute goes where.

Granulated sugar is 200 g per US cup and 211 g per metric cup.

Want a recipe that actually works, every Thursday?

Recipe of the week, one tip that saves you time and one deal from the shop. Unsubscribe in one click.

The next issue goes out on Thursday, November 26.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

Vanilla, flour and other swaps

  • No vanilla extract: leave it out, or use vanilla sugar (in Czech shops, vanilkový cukr, sold in small sachets) or a pinch of cinnamon. Banana carries the flavor anyway. See vanilla extract.

  • Whole wheat flour: replace up to half the all-purpose flour. The loaf is denser and nuttier, and the batter may need a spoon of extra liquid.

  • Gluten-free flour blend: use a blend made for cakes, weight for weight, and bake to a slightly higher center temperature. King Arthur Baking gives 96–99 °C (205–210 °F) for gluten-free banana bread. If you bake for someone with coeliac disease, check that every ingredient, including oats and baking powder, is labelled gluten-free; swapping the flour alone is not enough.

  • Nuts and chocolate: add up to about 100–150 g for a standard loaf; more makes it heavy.

  • Baking soda: if you are out, see baking soda substitutes.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use oil instead of butter in banana bread?

Yes. Use about three-quarters as much oil as butter by weight, for example about 85 g of oil in place of 113 g (1 US stick) of butter. Oil gives a moister, softer loaf that stays tender longer; butter gives more flavor.

Can I use butter instead of vegetable oil in banana bread?

Yes. Use about 1¼ times the oil's weight in melted butter, for example 125 g of butter for 100 g of oil, which gives the same amount of fat. The loaf will taste richer and be slightly firmer once cool, because butter is about a fifth water and sets as it cools.

What can I use instead of eggs in banana bread?

For each large egg, use about 60 g of unsweetened applesauce, 60 g of plain yogurt, or 1 tablespoon of ground flaxseed mixed with 3 tablespoons of water and left for 5 minutes. Replacing one egg works well; replacing all of them gives a denser loaf.

What can I substitute for sour cream in banana bread?

Full-fat Greek yogurt is the closest swap, weight for weight. Plain yogurt, crème fraîche or buttermilk also work; buttermilk is thinner, so use about three-quarters as much.

Can I reduce the sugar in banana bread?

Yes. Most cake-style recipes take a 10% cut without noticeable change, and up to about 25% works in many banana breads. Very ripe bananas add sweetness, but less sugar also means a paler, slightly drier loaf that goes stale sooner.

Can I use brown sugar instead of white sugar in banana bread?

Yes, swap it one for one by weight. Brown sugar gives a moister, darker loaf with a light caramel taste, which suits banana bread well.

Want tips like this every Thursday?

One recipe worth heating the oven for, one tip, and one deal from the shop. Nothing else.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

Cart