Classic christmas cookies: delicate linzer cookies
Silicone Baking Mat, Parchment Paper, or Greased Pan: Which to Use When
Silicone Baking Mat, Parchment Paper, or Greased Pan: Which to Use When
Updated Nov 3, 2026
A silicone baking mat pays off for sticky or delicate bakes you make often, parchment paper is the most versatile choice up to about 220 °C (428 °F; check the packaging), and a greased pan gives the best browning for vegetables, potatoes and bread rolls. It's not just about stopping things from sticking: each surface conducts heat differently and has a different amount of slip, so cookies spread and brown differently on each one. Here's what you get from each option, how to choose a silicone mat, and what to bake each type of Christmas cookie on.
Parchment Paper, Silicone Baking Mat, or Greased Pan: A Quick Comparison
In short: parchment for cookies and biscuits, silicone for sticky bakes and frequent baking, a greased pan for vegetables, potatoes and bread with a crisp bottom.
Parchment paper — up to about 220 °C (428 °F; check the packaging). Cookies hold their shape, edges are crisper, and you can easily slide finished bakes off the paper. Good for one to several uses.
Silicone baking mat — up to about 230–250 °C (445–480 °F), depending on the manufacturer. Nothing sticks to it, and it lasts hundreds of bakes. It's slippery, so dough spreads more; the bottoms tend to be paler.
Greased pan — no temperature limit, and the heat goes straight into the food. You get the best browning and crispness, but more washing up, and with sweet bakes there's a risk of sticking and burnt sugar.
Did that help? We’ll send you more tips by email.
Seasonal baking plans, tested recipes and kitchen tricks that save you time. Unsubscribe in one click.
When to Use Parchment Paper
Parchment paper is the best choice for most cookies, biscuits and meringues, and for lining cake pans. It's thin, so it lets heat through almost like a bare pan, but nothing sticks to it.
Cookies and biscuits: the dough "grips" the paper a little, holds its shape, and the edges turn golden. You can slide the whole sheet of finished cookies from the pan onto a cooling rack and reuse the pan right away.
Meringues and egg-white bakes: once cooled, they peel easily off the paper.
Cake pans and loaf pans: a paper circle for the bottom and a strip for the sides save you greasing and flouring.
Cooking in paper (en papillote): fish or vegetables wrapped in paper steam in their own moisture — like the salmon parcel below.
Watch the temperature. Most papers have a limit of around 220 °C (428 °F) on the packaging. Above that the paper browns, turns brittle and can scorch at the edges. For pizza at 250 °C (480 °F) and up, use it only as a helper for transferring the pizza, or pull it out after the first few minutes.
Tip for curling paper: crumple the sheet into a ball, unfold it and smooth it out, or put a dab of dough or butter in the corners of the pan as glue. Don't let the paper hang over the edge of the pan — in a fan oven it lifts up and can touch the heating element.
Classic shortbread-style linzer cookies — buttery cookies that keep sharp edges on parchment paper
Saumon au papillote, or salmon baked in a parcel
Salmon in a parchment parcel (en papillote) — fish steamed in its own moisture
When a Silicone Baking Mat Is Worth It
A silicone baking mat is worth it when you bake often and bake lots of sticky or delicate things: macarons, thin tuile wafers, caramel, pralines, marzipan, or sticky yeasted doughs that you work right on the mat.
Nothing sticks, even without fat — not even melted sugar.
It lasts hundreds of bakes — less waste than paper and, in the long run, less money.
Higher temperature limit — usually 230–250 °C (445–480 °F), depending on the manufacturer.
What to watch out for. In America's Test Kitchen tests, chocolate cookies came out about 6 mm (¼ inch) wider on a silicone mat than on parchment — the mat is slippery, so the dough spreads more. For the same reason, thinner edges can bake through and brown more, while the bottom in the middle tends to be paler on silicone. If you want taller, more compact cookies, reach for parchment — or a perforated mat that lets hot air through.
Care: never cut on the mat with a knife or pizza cutter, or you'll slice through it. Wash with warm water and a drop of dish soap; the rough side of a sponge will scratch it. Always put the mat on a baking sheet, not straight on the oven rack — without firm support it sags (according to the manufacturer, a perforated one can also go on the rack).
How to Choose a Silicone Baking Mat
Choose a silicone baking mat based on four things: whether it's solid or perforated, what temperature limit the manufacturer states, whether it fits your baking sheet, and how you'll care for it. You'll find a selection in all sizes among the baking mats and baking frames.
Solid or perforated. A solid mat has a continuous surface and suits anything sticky or runny: macarons, thin wafers, caramel, pralines. A perforated one has tiny holes that let hot air circulate under the bakes too, so the bottom stays drier and crisper. It suits cookies, cut-out cookies, choux pastry and bread. It's not suited to thin batters that would run through the holes.
Temperature limit. You'll find it on the packaging, commonly 230–250 °C (445–480 °F). If you often bake pizza or bread at 250 °C (480 °F) and up, check it before you buy a mat.
Size. The mat should lie flat inside the baking sheet. If it overhangs the edge or lifts at the sides, the dough at the edge won't bake evenly and the mat will crack at the fold.
Care. Fiberglass-reinforced silicone mats mustn't be cut or folded. The manufacturer states whether a mat can go in the dishwasher.
Before first use, wash the mat with warm water and dish soap and let it dry.
When a Greased Pan Is Enough
A greased pan is best where you want maximum browning and crispness: roasted vegetables, potatoes, meat, bread rolls, pizza and bread. Metal passes heat straight into the food, and the fat on the pan "fries" the bottom — neither paper nor silicone can do that.
Vegetables and potatoes: grease the pan with oil (1–2 tablespoons per pan is enough) and spread the vegetables in a single layer so they don't steam.
Pizza and bread: at 250 °C (480 °F) and up, a bare or lightly oiled pan (or a preheated stone) is safer than paper.
Cakes in a pan: grease the pan with softened butter and dust with flour — a thin layer of flour stops sticking, and the cake releases from the sides.
Careful with sweet bakes. Fat on the pan gives cookies a slippery base, so they spread more. Butter doughs such as linzer cookies or vanilla crescents have plenty of fat and won't stick to a clean pan — you don't even need to grease it. On the other hand, anything with caramelizing sugar, honey or a fruit filling will stick to a bare pan and burn; that's where paper belongs.
The perfect homemade pizza
The perfect homemade pizza — a crisp bottom on a hot pan with no parchment paper
Homemade bread
Homemade bread — a crust that loves a hot pan or stone
Roasted vegetable salad with feta
Roasted vegetable and feta salad — vegetables that do best on a greased pan
The best christmas cookies? vanilla crescents, of course!
Vanilla crescents — a butter dough that won't stick even to a clean pan
What to Bake Christmas Cookies On: Parchment or a Silicone Mat?
Bake most Christmas cookies on parchment paper or on a perforated silicone mat, never on a greased pan. A solid silicone mat is worth it for pieces with caramel, honey or a sticky filling, and a bare pan only for butter doughs that have plenty of fat. By type:
Linzer and cut-out cookies: parchment or a perforated mat. On a solid silicone mat, butter dough spreads more and sharp edges get rounded. Why linzer cookies spread and how to prevent it is covered in the article why linzer cookies spread when baking.
Vanilla crescents: parchment, or simply a clean ungreased pan. The butter dough won't stick, and the bottoms turn an even golden color.
Gingerbread cookies: parchment or a silicone mat. Honey dough sticks easily to a bare pan, and the bottom darkens before the cookie is baked through.
Meringues and egg-white bakes: parchment. Once cooled, they peel off whole; on silicone the bottoms dry more slowly.
Piped cookies: parchment or a bare ungreased pan. The dough has to grip the surface, or it lifts with the nozzle as you pipe. How to make piped cookies without a cookie press is shown in the article spritz-style cookies without a cookie press.
Pieces with caramel, honey or a fruit filling: parchment or a solid silicone mat. You can peel any leaked sugar off them afterward.
Whatever you bake on, put each following tray into the oven cold and let the oven preheat properly. You can find out how far your oven is from the set temperature with a thermometer; more in the article how to find out your oven's true temperature. Temperatures for the individual types are summarized in the overview what temperature to bake cookies at.
Why Do Cookies Bake Differently on Each Surface?
Cookies bake differently on parchment paper, a silicone mat and a greased pan because of three things: heat conduction, surface friction and browning of the bottom.
Heat conduction. A bare metal pan passes on heat fastest, paper is thin and slows it only slightly, and silicone slows it the most. The more slowly the bottom heats up, the later the dough sets and the longer it can spread.
Friction. Paper has a slightly rough surface that the dough can "grip". Silicone, and especially a greased pan, are slippery, so the melted butter and dough spread outward — and the thin edges then brown faster.
Browning of the bottom. Direct contact with metal (and fat) gives the darkest, crispiest bottom. On silicone, the bottom in the middle tends to be the palest.
The practical upshot: if you switch from paper to silicone and your cookies are spreading, chill the dough for 20–30 minutes before baking, or leave more space between them.
Most Common Mistakes with Parchment, Silicone Mats and Baking Sheets
There are six common mistakes: mixing up parchment paper with wax or sandwich paper, foil under sweet bakes, paper above its temperature limit, cutting on a silicone mat, a greased pan under delicate cookies, and putting dough on a hot pan.
Mixing up parchment paper with sandwich paper or wax paper. Wax paper doesn't belong in the oven; the wax melts and smokes.
Foil instead of paper for sweet bakes. Foil has no non-stick coating, cookies stick to it, and the bottoms burn faster. For vegetables or meat lightly brushed with oil, though, it does the job.
Paper above the limit on the packaging. At 250 °C (480 °F), paper browns and turns brittle within a few minutes.
Cutting on a silicone mat. One cut and the mat is ready for the bin.
A greased pan for delicate cookies. The extra fat makes cookies spread, and the bottom can darken before the top is done.
Raw dough on a hot pan. Whatever you use, put the next batch on a cooled pan or a fresh sheet of paper, or the dough starts to spread before it even gets into the oven.
Handy for your cookie baking
Frequently asked questions
Can you reuse parchment paper?
You can reuse parchment paper if it's still whole, clean and not browned — for dry cookies, a sheet can easily last three or four trays. Once it's greasy, brittle or dark, throw it away; browned paper cracks and loses its non-stick coating. There are also thicker reusable silicone-coated papers that, according to the manufacturers, last for more bakes — you'll find the number on the packaging.
Which side of parchment paper goes on the baking sheet?
With ordinary parchment paper it doesn't matter which side you lay down, as both sides are non-stick. If the manufacturer says otherwise on the packaging, follow the packaging. If the paper curls, lay it with the inside of the roll facing down, or anchor it in the corners with a dab of dough.
Can I put parchment paper in the microwave?
Yes, you can put parchment paper in the microwave — it contains no metal and works for covering food to stop splatters, or as a liner under baked goods you're reheating. It mustn't touch the walls or reach an exposed grill element if your microwave has a grill function; the same temperature limit applies there as in the oven.
Why do my bakes stick to parchment paper?
Bakes most often stick to parchment paper because they're underbaked, still hot, or the paper has lost its non-stick layer from repeated use. Let meringues and egg-white bakes cool completely; for sugar or cheese fillings that leak out and caramelize, lightly greasing the paper helps. Cheaper papers tend to have a thinner silicone coating, so they start sticking sooner.
How do you clean a stiff or greasy silicone baking mat?
Soak a stiff or greasy silicone mat for 15–20 minutes in hot water with a drop of dish soap, then wipe it with the soft side of a sponge. Ingrained grease responds to a paste of baking soda and water. Don't use steel wool or sharp objects, as they scratch the surface.
Do you need to grease a silicone baking mat?
You don't need to grease a silicone baking mat — it's non-stick on its own. Extra fat would make the dough slide even more on the slippery silicone, and over time it builds up a sticky film on the mat's surface that's hard to remove.
Want tips like this every Thursday?
One recipe worth heating the oven for, one tip, and one deal from the shop. Nothing else.