At a glance
This classic tomato sauce is a labor of love that rewards patience with rich, velvety results—you'll sear beef shoulder, braise it until tender with aromatic spices, then build a smooth sauce by making a roux, adding tomatoes, and finishing with a whisking of cold butter for silky perfection. The three-hour total time (most of which is hands-off braising) yields a deeply flavored sauce that's slightly sweet and aromatic, perfect with meatballs, dumplings, or braised beef.
-
1/11
Brown the meat with onion
Season the beef shoulder slices with salt and pepper on both sides. In a large heavy-bottomed pot, ideally cast iron, heat a little oil and brown the meat on all sides. Add two roughly chopped onions and let them soften alongside the meat for a while. Don't crowd the pot, so the meat browns rather than steams; if it doesn't all fit, brown it in two batches.
For this step
0/5 -
2/11
Add water and braise with spices
Pour in water until the meat is fully submerged. Tie the allspice, bay leaf, cinnamon and star anise in a piece of cheesecloth so you can lift them out easily, and drop the bundle into the pot. Cover and braise over low heat until tender; allow a little under two hours. It's done when a fork slides in with no resistance. Keep the liquid at a gentle bubble, since a hard boil dries the meat out.
For this step
0/4 -
3/11
Speed it up with a pressure cooker
If you're short on time, braise the meat in a pressure cooker. It turns tender much sooner than in a regular pot.
How it went
Nobody has tried this recipe yet
Be the first to say how it went.
Anyone can answer, without signing in or buying. Answers aren't verified. The percentage is the share of “Worked out” answers, shown from 5 answers.
Tips from the Yumsto kitchen
Why it works
The sauce isn't built on water but on the broth the meat braised in with allspice, bay leaf, cinnamon and star anise. Reducing it to about half a liter concentrates the flavor. Onion caramelized with cane sugar balances the acidity of the tomatoes, and the roux gives the sauce body. Cold butter whisked in off the heat makes it silky and glossy at the end.
Tips
Cut the shoulder into slices of even thickness so they turn tender at the same time. Let the roux cook in the pan for a moment, as raw flour would come through in the sauce. Don't skip the sieve; it's what makes the sauce truly smooth. If it turns out too thick, thin it with a spoonful of broth or water; if it's thin, simmer it uncovered a little longer.
Variations
Instead of shoulder, you can use another braising cut of beef, such as shank; it takes a little longer and the sauce turns more gelatinous. Tomato paste can be swapped for canned crushed tomatoes; the sauce will be lighter and more acidic, so adjust it with sugar. Without the beef, you can make it with ready meatballs and stock instead of water.
Storage
Let the sauce with the meat cool for no more than 2 hours, then keep it in a sealed container in the fridge for up to 3 days. You can freeze it for up to 3 months. Reheat it slowly, stirring, until it's piping hot throughout; a sauce finished with butter may split at a hard boil, in which case just whisk it again.
Serving
The classic pairing is Czech bread dumplings, and it's also popular with rice or pasta. Spoon plenty of sauce over the meat slices.
Common questions
Why does this tomato sauce use cinnamon and star anise?
Whole spices give the broth a gently sweet aroma that's typical of Czech tomato sauce. Tied in cheesecloth, they're easy to remove, so no hard bits end up in the sauce.
Do I have to strain the sauce?
You don't have to, but after blending it still has fine onion fibers. A fine sieve makes it velvety.
Why is the butter added at the very end?
Cold butter whisked into hot sauce off the heat forms a light emulsion that makes the sauce silky and glossy. If the sauce boiled afterward, the butter would separate.
Can I make it faster?
Yes, braise the meat in a pressure cooker and it turns tender much sooner. The rest of the method stays the same.
Featured in our guides
Want a recipe like this every Thursday?
One recipe worth heating the oven for, and one tip that saves you time. Nothing else.