Choose your cookies

Necessary cookies hold the site together — cart, sign-in, language. Analytics ones show us what works here and what to build your recommendations on. Marketing ones would measure ads outside Yumsto; we're not running any yet. Nothing but the necessary ones runs until you say yes.

How we handle your data

Cookie settings

Czech vs German vs American Potato Salad: What's the Difference?

Czech vs German vs American Potato Salad: What's the Difference?

A realistic overhead food photo of three bowls of potato salad side by side on a wooden table: a creamy finely diced Czech salad with carrot, peas and pickles, a glossy warm German salad with sliced potatoes, onion and chives, and a creamy American salad with celery, egg and paprika, no text, no peo

Updated Nov 20, 2026

Czech potato salad is a cold mayonnaise salad with finely diced cooked root vegetables, pickles, peas, onion and egg, and it is the classic side for fried carp on Christmas Eve. Southern German potato salad has no mayonnaise at all: warm potatoes are dressed with broth, vinegar, oil and onion. American potato salad is a creamy mayonnaise and mustard salad with celery, onion and often egg and pickle relish.

Czech, German and American potato salad at a glance

All three start with boiled potatoes. What happens next is where they part ways:

  • Czech (bramborový salát): cold, mayonnaise-based, finely diced, with cooked root vegetables, pickles, peas, onion and egg. A Christmas Eve essential.

  • German, southern style (Swabian or Bavarian Kartoffelsalat): warm or lukewarm, no mayonnaise, sliced potatoes dressed with broth, vinegar, oil and onion. Glossy and tangy.

  • German, northern style: cold and mayonnaise-based, usually with pickles and sometimes egg or apple.

  • American: cold, creamy, chunkier, dressed with mayonnaise and mustard, with crunchy raw celery and onion, often hard-boiled egg and pickle relish, and a dusting of paprika.

The Czech version is closest to the northern German and Russian-style mayonnaise salads. The southern German one is a different dish altogether.

Did that help? We’ll send you more tips by email.

Seasonal baking plans, tested recipes and kitchen tricks that save you time. Unsubscribe in one click.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

What is in Czech potato salad?

Every Czech family has its own version and will defend it, but the core is the same:

  • Waxy potatoes, boiled in their skins, peeled and diced small.

  • Cooked root vegetables: carrot, celeriac (celery root) and often parsley root, diced as small as the potatoes.

  • Pickles: sweet-sour Czech-style pickled cucumbers, diced, and often a splash of their brine.

  • Onion, chopped fine.

  • Peas, usually from a can or jar.

  • Hard-boiled eggs, chopped.

  • Mayonnaise, usually store-bought, often with a spoon of mustard. Some cooks swap part of it for yogurt.

Some households add ham, salami or apple. In outline, the potatoes are the main ingredient by weight, with the vegetables, pickles and egg making up a smaller share, and the mayonnaise is added last, just enough to bind.

The vegetables are cut into small, even cubes, so every forkful has a bit of everything. For which potatoes hold their shape, see the best potatoes for potato salad.

Czech potato salad and Christmas Eve carp

On 24 December, Czech families traditionally eat fried carp in breadcrumbs with potato salad. Families who don't like fish usually have schnitzel instead, but the salad stays.

Because Christmas Eve is busy, the salad is almost always made the day before. It goes into a large bowl, covered, in the fridge, overnight, so the vegetables, pickles and mayonnaise settle together. It comes out shortly before dinner.

If you are cooking for a crowd, our guide to how much carp and potato salad per person helps with quantities, and why fried carp falls apart covers the fish.

What is German potato salad?

When Americans say German potato salad, they usually mean the southern style. In Swabia and Bavaria, Kartoffelsalat is made like this, in outline:

  • Waxy potatoes are boiled, peeled and sliced while still warm.

  • The slices are dressed with hot broth, vinegar, oil and finely chopped onion, often with a little mustard, salt and pepper.

  • The potatoes soak up the dressing and turn creamy and glossy without any mayonnaise.

  • Chives go on top, and it is served warm or at room temperature, often with sausages, Leberkäse or schnitzel.

The American take on German potato salad often adds fried bacon and its fat and a bit of sugar to the vinegar dressing, and is served hot.

In northern Germany, potato salad is more often cold and made with mayonnaise, pickles and egg, much closer to the Czech version.

What is American potato salad?

Classic American potato salad is a picnic and barbecue side. It is usually:

  • Chunkier: potatoes cut into larger cubes, sometimes with the skin on.

  • Creamy and tangy: mayonnaise plus yellow or Dijon mustard, sometimes a little vinegar or pickle juice.

  • Crunchy: raw celery and onion, which the Czech version doesn't use.

  • Often with egg and pickle relish, and paprika on top.

There are regional styles too, with more mustard in the South and versions with bacon or herbs elsewhere. Compared with it, Czech potato salad is finer, more sour from the pickles, and gets its sweetness from cooked carrot and root vegetables rather than relish.

If your salad of any style turns runny, see why your potato salad is watery and how to fix it.

How to make Czech potato salad outside Czechia

Most of what goes into a Czech potato salad is easy to find in the US, UK, Canada or Australia. A few things need a swap:

  • Celeriac is sold as celery root in the US. Use the knobbly root, not celery stalks, and cook it with the carrot. Our page on celeriac shows what to look for.

  • Parsley root is hard to find outside Central Europe. A small parsnip is the usual stand-in, or simply leave it out and add a little more carrot.

  • Czech pickles are sweet-sour and mild, with dill, mustard seed and onion in the jar. Polish or German jarred gherkins are the closest. Bread-and-butter pickles are too sweet and kosher dills are saltier and sharper, so taste and adjust with a little sugar or brine.

  • Potatoes: choose waxy or salad potatoes, such as red potatoes or Yukon Gold (an all-purpose variety that holds its shape) in the US, or Charlotte in the UK. Floury baking potatoes break up and turn the salad mushy.

  • Mayonnaise: any good store-bought full-fat mayonnaise works.

Cut everything small and even, add the mayonnaise last, and season with salt, pepper and a splash of pickle brine. Then let it rest, covered, in the fridge, before serving. Czech cooks taste it again the next day, because the flavor changes overnight.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Czech and American potato salad?

Czech potato salad has finely diced cooked carrot, celeriac and parsley root, plus pickles, peas and onion, all in mayonnaise, while American potato salad is chunkier and built on mayonnaise and mustard with raw celery and onion. Both often include hard-boiled egg.

Does German potato salad have mayonnaise?

Southern German potato salad, from Swabia and Bavaria, has no mayonnaise: it is dressed with broth, vinegar, oil and onion, and served warm or lukewarm. Northern German potato salad usually does use mayonnaise, often with pickles and egg.

Why do Czechs eat potato salad on Christmas Eve?

Czechs eat potato salad on Christmas Eve because it is the traditional side for fried carp, the classic Christmas Eve main course. Families that skip the fish serve it with schnitzel instead.

Should Czech potato salad be made the day before?

Yes, Czech potato salad is usually made the day before and kept covered, in the fridge, overnight so the flavors settle. For how long it keeps after that, see our article on how long potato salad lasts in the fridge.

Is German potato salad served warm or cold?

Southern German potato salad is traditionally served warm or at room temperature, soon after the warm potatoes are dressed. The mayonnaise-based northern style is served cold.

Want tips like this every Thursday?

One recipe worth heating the oven for, one tip, and one deal from the shop. Nothing else.

No spam. What we do with emails is in our Privacy policy

Cart